当前课程知识点:创新土地再开发:土地整备 > Module 3: Policy Goals of Land Readjustment 第三单元:土地整备的政策目标 > Myths About Adopting Land Readjustment 关于土地整备的谬见 > Myth #2: Clearly Delineated Property Rights
There have been rigorous debates about the need for clearly delineated property rights to implement land readjustment. On one hand, proponents argue for establishing a clear property right regime prior to any adoption of land readjustment, because it involves the swapping of property. Without formal knowledge or records of who owns what, land readjustment would be very difficult to implement. On the other hand, opponents argue that property relations in most developing countries are not clearly defined. It would take a long time and tremendous effort to clarify property relations, especially in situations where informality dominates. In other words, a legal titling requirement could make land readjustment of little use in some developing countries. The video below presents both arguments based on land readjustment experiences in selected developing countries.
对于实行土地整备时,是否需要清晰的产权划分,已经有了严谨的辩论。一方面,支持者认为,实行土地整备前,应当建立清晰的产权制度,因为土地整备涉及土地置换。如果对产权所属没有清晰的了解或记录,将难以实行土地整备。另一方面,反对者认为,大多数发展中国家产权关系不明确, 需要耗费很长的时间和精力来明晰产权关系,尤其是非正式居住占据主导的情况下。换言之,在某些发展中国家,要求法律赋予所有权可能会使土地整备收效甚微。以下视频选取了部分发展中国家,根据它们土地整备的经验展现了这两种观点。
-Welcome 欢迎辞
--Welcome
-Course Welcome 课程欢迎辞
-How to Use This Course 如何学习本课程
-Who's Teaching This Course 教师信息
-Learning Objectives 学习目标
-Course Schedule 课程安排
-Grading and Completion Criteria 评分与结业标准
--Grading and Completion Criteria
-Introduction 介绍
-Defining Land Readjustment 土地整备定义
--A Working Definition of Land Readjustment
--Introduction to Land Readjustment
--Questions
--Text
--Challenges of Rapid Urbanization in Developing Countries
--Challenges of Rapid Urbanization
--Questions
--Text
-Conventional Approaches to Solving Problems of Rapid Urbanization 解决快速城市化问题的传统方法
--Conventional Land Assembly Apporach
--Questions
--Text
-Land Readjustment as an Alternative 土地整备作为一种替代方法
--Land Readjustment as an Alternative
--Land Readjustment as an Alternative
--Questions
--Text
-Course Structure 课程结构
--Text
-Discussion and Application 讨论和应用
--Text
--Text
-Introduction 简介
--Introduction to Land Readjustment
--Text
-The Evolution of Land Readjustment 土地整备的发展历程
--The Early Development Stages of Land Readjustment
--The Early Development Stages of Land Readjustment
--Questions
--Text
--The Diversity of Land Readjustment
--Diversity of Land Readjustment
--Questions
--Text
-Land Readjustment Examples 土地整备的案例
--Text
--Text
--Turkey
--Questions
--Text
--文本
--Text
--Text
--Questions
--Text
--Post-conflict and Post-disaster Reconstruction
--Angola
--Text
--Text
--Chile
--Questions
--Text
-Wrap Up 结语
--Lessons from Global Examples
--Questions
--Text
--Key Concept Review 2--General observations
--Questions
--Text
-Discussion and Application 讨论和应用
--Module 2: International Experiences with Land Readjustment
--Text
--Text
-Introduction 简介
--Text
--Text
-Conceptualizing Land Readjustment Goals 概念化土地整备目标
--Conceptualizing Land Readjustment Goals
--Policy Goals of Land Readjustment
--Questions
--Text
-Myths About Adopting Land Readjustment 关于土地整备的谬见
--Myth #1: The Need for Land Readjustment Legislation
--Myth #1
--Text
--Example: Informal Settlement Upgrading in Ethiopia
--Questions
--Text
--Myth #2: Clearly Delineated Property Rights
--Myth #2
--Text
--Example: Urban Village Redevelopment in China
--Questions
--Text
--Myth #3: The Existence of a Buoyant Real Estate Market
--Myth #3
--Text
--Questions
--Text
--Myth #4: An Organized Community
--Myth #4
--Text
--Questions
--Text
--Myth #5: Trust Relations Among Stakeholders
--Myth #5
--Text
--Questions
--Text
-Preconditions for Adopting Land Readjustment 采纳土地整备的前提
--Questions
--Text
-Wrap Up 结语
--Questions
--Text
-Introduction 简介
--Text
-Important Considerations 重要考量因素
--Questions
--Text
-Context Assessment 环境评估
--Assessing Each Component of the Larger Environment
--Questions
--Text
-Initiation and Preparation 发起和准备
--Text
--Preparation and Organization
--Questions
--Text
-Design and Approval 设计与审批
--Design
--Text
--Calculation of Land Contribution Ratios
--Text
--Approval
--Questions
--Text
-Implementation and Completion 实施与完工
--Implementation and Completion
--Text
--Questions
--Text
-Evaluation and Scaling Up 评估与扩展
--Questions
--Text
-Wrap Up 总结
--Questions
--Text
-Main Takeaways 知识要点
--Takeaways of the Entire Course
--Takeaways of The Entire Course
--Questions
--Text
--Questions
--Text
--Questions
--Text
-Application Activity 应用练习
--Text
-Evaluation 评估
-Acknowledgements 致谢